We are on company holidays from December 20th, 2024 to January 10th, 2025 and until then we wish you a Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year 2025.

Good To Know PunchOut vs. content catalog: Which solution is a better fit?

The world of e-procurement offers various options for optimizing purchasing. Two commonly used methods are the PunchOut catalog and the Content catalog. But what are the differences and which solution is best suited to your company's needs?

Reading time 5 minutes
PunchOut vs. content catalog: Which solution is a better fit?

In modern procurement, companies are increasingly relying on digital solutions to make the purchasing process more efficient. PunchOut and content catalogs play a central role in this. Both approaches offer different advantages, depending on a company's priorities - be it access to up-to-date data, a broad product range or simple, user-friendly integration. In this article, we will introduce you to the two catalog types and their special features.

What is a PunchOut catalog?

A PunchOut catalog is an integration where the buyer is redirected from an e-procurement platform (e.g. SAP Ariba) to the supplier's external website to select products. After selecting the products, the buyer returns to the platform to complete the purchase.

What is a content catalog?

A content catalog is a product catalog provided by the supplier for its customers. It is stored directly in the company's e-procurement system. Buyers can access the catalog without leaving the system and thus select products and place orders.

A content catalog is a product catalog provided by the supplier for its customers. It is stored directly in the company's e-procurement system. Buyers can access the catalog without leaving the system and thus select products and place orders.

There are also hybrid forms such as PunchOut Level 2, in which a content catalog with basic item data is integrated into the procurement system. In this model, prices can only be retrieved from the supplier system when the products are actually placed in the shopping cart. This enables efficient use of current price information, while at the same time taking advantage of the benefits of a central catalog.

Differences between the PunchOut and Content catalogs

In the following, we take a closer look at the main differences. To do this, we compare PunchOut and Content catalogs in terms of data storage, updating, user experience and other key criteria, which we have presented to you in the following list:

  • Data storage: the PunchOut catalog stores the product data externally on the supplier's website, while the Content catalog stores this data directly in the e-procurement system.

  • Product updating: The PunchOut catalog is automatically updated by the supplier, whereas manual intervention is required for the content catalog, which requires regular maintenance to keep product information, prices and availability up to date. This can be time-consuming and labor-intensive, especially with extensive product ranges, as every adjustment has to be made directly in the catalog.

  • User experience: With a PunchOut catalog, the user switches between different systems, while the content catalog offers a consistent user experience within the e-procurement system.

  • Product diversity: A PunchOut catalog provides access to the supplier's full product range, whereas a content catalog usually only shows a limited number of products. This is because a content catalog is stored within the e-procurement system and is therefore subject to storage and maintenance requirements. In order to optimize performance and loading times, it is often decided to display only selected products or core product ranges.

  • Integration: The integration of a PunchOut catalog is more complex as external websites need to be integrated, while the content catalog is easier to integrate as it is hosted within the system.

  • Price updates and ordering process: PunchOut catalogs show prices in real time, while content catalogs require regular updates. The ordering process also differs: with the PunchOut catalog, an external shopping cart is transferred to the internal system, whereas with the content catalog, the order is placed entirely internally.

The advantages and disadvantages of a PunchOut catalog

A PunchOut catalog offers numerous advantages. It provides access to constantly updated data, which is particularly useful for prices and product availability. Another advantage is full access to the supplier's entire product portfolio, including individual offers. The automatic updates also relieve the burden on purchasing, as manual updates are no longer necessary.

However, the advantages are offset by a number of challenges. For example, dependence on the supplier means that access to the catalog is not possible in the event of technical problems or outages. The costs for implementation and maintenance can also be considerable. Finally, switching between systems can disrupt the workflow in the company and impair the user experience.

The advantages and disadvantages of a content catalog

The content catalog scores points for its simple integration and user-friendliness. As all products are available directly in the e-procurement system, the ordering process is efficient and does not require a system change. This solution is also more cost-effective and less resource-intensive to maintain. However, the content catalog also has disadvantages. Price and product updates have to be carried out manually, which is time-consuming and can lead to outdated data. In addition, the variety of products is limited, which can restrict flexibility when purchasing.

Hidden costs in comparison: PunchOut catalog vs. content catalog

Both types of catalog come with hidden costs in addition to the obvious ones. PunchOut catalogs incur implementation and maintenance costs, among other things, which are often higher than initially thought. In addition, dependence on the supplier can also lead to further costs.

With the content catalog, manual maintenance and updating of the catalogs in particular cause ongoing costs. Outdated data can also lead to incorrect orders and thus to indirect costs that often only become apparent after the fact.

Is a PunchOut or a content catalog better suited to my company?

The decision between a PunchOut and a content catalog depends largely on the individual requirements and resources of your company.

While PunchOut catalogs are best suited for companies that prioritize a comprehensive product range and up-to-date data, content catalogs offer a simpler and more cost-effective solution for companies that are satisfied with a smaller product selection and a user-friendly interface.

If you have any questions or suggestions, just send us an email hallo@punchcommerce.de or call us at +49 6142 / 953 80 - 60. We appreciate your feedback!

Back to the journal

Fancy a Test? Start the non-binding 30-day test phase.

PunchCommerce® ist ein Produkt der Netzdirektion GmbH