PunchOut vs. content catalog: the difference for suppliers | PunchCommerce                       ![](//analytics.punchcommerce.de/matomo.php?idsite=1&rec=1)

  [Skip to content](#main-content)

   Know-how · Comparison  PunchOut vs. content catalog. Your customer asks for a catalog, you choose the route.
=======================================================================================

 A content catalog is a file with your items that your customer imports into their system. A PunchOut catalog is access to your range, which stays with you. Both have their place, and both can be combined.

 [ Start free trial ](https://www.punchcommerce.de/register) [ View comparison ](#comparison)

30 days free · no credit card · cancel anytime

  file, access or both 3 routes

 setup without an IT project &lt; 1 h

 free trial 30 days

 Short answer

The difference in brief
-----------------------

 The difference lies in where your item data is held: with a content catalog, it sits as a copy in your customer’s system; with a PunchOut catalog, it stays with you. With a content catalog, the buyer searches and orders in their own system and sees the state of the last file; with a PunchOut catalog, they switch to your catalog, see your current range with their prices and transfer the cart back.

### PunchOut catalog: access to your range

  What you deliver a PunchOut URL plus credentials per customer, no file

 Where the data is held with you, in your shop or in the Hosted Catalog; the buyer jumps in via OCI or cXML and transfers the cart back

 What you maintain range and prices once; your customer always sees the current state

### Content catalog: your items as a file

  What you deliver a catalog file in your customer’s format

 Where the data is held copied into your customer’s system, next to the catalogs of other suppliers

 What you maintain after every change, a new file that your customer checks and imports

For you, what changes is what you deliver and what you maintain afterwards: a new file for every change, or an access that always shows your current state. Which variant is usually decided by your customer; some ask for both.

 What a PunchOut catalog is exactly and what your customer needs from you for it is explained on the page about the [PunchOut catalog](https://www.punchcommerce.de/en/punchout-catalog); the two protocols on [OCI PunchOut](https://www.punchcommerce.de/en/oci-punchout) and [cXML PunchOut](https://www.punchcommerce.de/en/cxml-punchout), the process itself in the [PunchOut basics](https://www.punchcommerce.de/en/punchout).

 Comparison

PunchOut catalog and content catalog compared directly
------------------------------------------------------

Neither variant is better in principle. The overview shows where each has its strengths and what it costs you in day-to-day operation.

  Comparison of PunchOut catalog and content catalog by criteria   Criterion PunchOut catalog Content catalog     Data storage  PunchOut catalog with you, in your shop or in the Hosted Catalog, hosted in Germany in compliance with the GDPR   Content catalog as a copy in your customer’s procurement system    Freshness  PunchOut catalog every call shows your current state   Content catalog state of the most recently imported file    Maintenance effort  PunchOut catalog you maintain range and prices once; per customer only credentials and, if needed, a field mapping   Content catalog after every change, create a new file that your customer checks and imports    Range breadth  PunchOut catalog your full range, without your customer having to import it   Content catalog often limited to an agreed core range, because every item is imported and maintained    Search  PunchOut catalog the buyer switches to your catalog and searches there   Content catalog the buyer searches in their own system, without switching systems and next to other suppliers    Customer-specific prices  PunchOut catalog via the credentials per customer, changes apply immediately   Content catalog a separate file per customer, changes only after the next import    Ordering route  PunchOut catalog the cart comes back via OCI or cXML and becomes a purchase requisition   Content catalog the buyer creates the purchase requisition directly in their own system    Order to you  PunchOut and content catalog for both, after approval through the agreed channel, for example by email, EDI or as a cXML order document    Availability  PunchOut catalog your catalog has to be available when the buyer opens it   Content catalog usable even when your system is currently unavailable    Costs  PunchOut catalog with PunchCommerce €49 per customer per month, without a shop plus the Hosted Catalog add-on at €50, each plus VAT; built in-house, effort for the interface and its operation   Content catalog no license required; effort for creating the file, adapting the format and every update    What you deliver  PunchOut catalog a PunchOut URL and separate credentials for each customer   Content catalog a catalog file in the format your customer specifies

 Decision guide

What do you deliver to your customer?
-------------------------------------

Your customer’s request usually already reveals which variant is meant. Three typical cases:

If your customer …

### only asks for a catalog file

 → content catalogThen you deliver the file in the format your customer specifies and ask how often they expect updates. You do not need PunchCommerce for this. If you use the Hosted Catalog anyway, it exports the file as well, as a CIF file or OCI JSON.

 [Go to the Hosted Catalog](https://www.punchcommerce.de/en/hosted-catalog)

If your customer …

### wants a PunchOut catalog

 → PunchOut catalogThen you deliver a PunchOut URL and credentials, not a file. With your own shop via a plugin, without a shop via the Hosted Catalog. Your customer always sees your current state.

 [Go to the PunchOut catalog](https://www.punchcommerce.de/en/punchout-catalog)

If your customer …

### wants both

 → PunchOut Level 2Search in their own system, cart from your catalog: in addition to the PunchOut URL and credentials, you deliver a catalog file.

 [Go to PunchOut Level 1 vs. Level 2](https://www.punchcommerce.de/en/punchout-level-1-vs-level-2)

 Hybrid

 File and PunchOut together: PunchOut Level 2
----------------------------------------------

 Many customers want both: your items should appear in their own system’s search, but the cart should come from your catalog with your current data. That is exactly PunchOut Level 2. Your customer imports a catalog file with your items, the buyer finds them in their search and jumps from there straight to the matching item page in your catalog. They transfer the cart as with any PunchOut.

 To be clear### The Hosted Catalog is a PunchOut catalog

 The name can be misleading: the Hosted Catalog is not a content catalog. Your items do not sit in your customer’s system but in a catalog that PunchCommerce runs for you. The buyer jumps in via PunchOut and transfers the cart back, just as with a connected shop. For suppliers without their own online shop, this is the route to the PunchOut catalog.

 [Go to the Hosted Catalog](https://www.punchcommerce.de/en/hosted-catalog)

 If your customer asks for a file### The catalog file comes from the Hosted Catalog

 If your customer asks for a catalog file, PunchCommerce exports it from the Hosted Catalog: for cXML as a CIF file, the catalog format of SAP Ariba, and for OCI 5.0 as JSON. So you maintain your items in one place and deliver both the PunchOut catalog and the file from there. With your own shop, you also add the items for the file to the Hosted Catalog or use a second customer entry. An example of a system where your customer can require both is Onventis, which has its own JSON format: [PunchOut for Onventis](https://www.punchcommerce.de/en/punchout-onventis).

 [Go to PunchOut Level 1 vs. Level 2](https://www.punchcommerce.de/en/punchout-level-1-vs-level-2)

 FAQ

Frequently asked questions about PunchOut and content catalogs
--------------------------------------------------------------

What suppliers want to know when their customer asks for a catalog and it is unclear which one is meant.

 ###   Is a PunchOut catalog more effort than a catalog file? +

 If you build it yourself, yes: protocols, credentials and the return have to be implemented and run permanently. With PunchCommerce, you install a plugin or upload your items to the Hosted Catalog; your side is usually set up in less than an hour. On your customer’s side, the effort is comparable, because a catalog file also has to be checked, imported and approved. With the file, that repeats with every update.

###   When is a content catalog the better choice? +

 When your range is manageable, prices rarely change and your customer explicitly wants everything in their own system. A file that you update once or twice a year is then often the simplest route. If prices change frequently or your range is large, the maintenance effort grows with every file.

###   Is the Hosted Catalog a content catalog? +

 No. The Hosted Catalog is a PunchOut catalog that PunchCommerce runs for you. Your items sit with PunchCommerce, not in your customer’s system; the buyer jumps in via PunchOut. If your customer also asks for a file, PunchCommerce exports it from the Hosted Catalog: for cXML as a CIF file, the catalog format of SAP Ariba, and for OCI 5.0 as JSON.

###   Can I combine a PunchOut catalog and a catalog file? +

 Yes, that is PunchOut Level 2. Your customer imports the file for their search, and the buyer still gets the cart from your catalog. The comparison [PunchOut Level 1 vs. Level 2](https://www.punchcommerce.de/en/punchout-level-1-vs-level-2) shows how this works.

###   How do the costs compare? +

 With PunchCommerce Business, you pay €49 per connected customer per month, plus VAT. Without your own shop, the Hosted Catalog add-on is added at €50 per customer per month, also plus VAT. A catalog file costs no license but working time: for creating it, adapting it to your customer’s format and every update.

  Get started

 Your customer asks for a catalog? Deliver it today.
-----------------------------------------------------

 €49 per customer per month, plus VAT; without your own shop plus the Hosted Catalog add-on at €50 per customer per month. Set up the PunchOut catalog and, if needed, export the catalog file from the Hosted Catalog, done.

 [ Start free trial ](https://www.punchcommerce.de/register)30 days free · no credit card · cancel anytime

 ![Patrick Dornbusch, founder of PunchCommerce](https://www.punchcommerce.de/static/patrick-dornbusch.webp)Patrick Dornbusch

Founder of PunchCommerce

Prefer to talk first? In 30 minutes we’ll work out which option suits your shop, your ERP and your customers’ procurement systems.

 [ Schedule a consultation  (opens in a new window) ](https://account.netzdirektion.de/appointments/punchcommerce)30 min · remote · with the founder

 PunchCommerce® is a product of [ ![netzdirektion | Gesellschaft für digitale Wertarbeit mbH](https://www.punchcommerce.de/static/netzdirektion-logo.png) (opens in a new window) ](https://netzdirektion.de) ![DEKRA seal: quality management according to ISO 9001](https://www.punchcommerce.de/static/dekra-netzdirektion-iso-9001.png) **ISO 9001:2015**
certified quality management

 netzdirektion | Gesellschaft für digitale Wertarbeit mbH · © 2020 - 2026
